“Whale Talk,” by Chris Crutcher

“Whale Talk,” by Chris Crutcher is an novel about the fight between misfits and popular people.

Author Chris Crutcher touches on many different issues within “Whale Talk.” The main character, T. J. Jones, aka The Tao Jones, is a multi-racial boy who is both smart and athletic. However, he shuns team sports at his school because he doesn't like the attitude of the “jocks” who make up the school's prominent teams. Even the coaches and organizers are racist and cruel to animals.

Although T. J. Jones has always refused to support the organized sports at his school, he sees an opportunity to get back at coaches and athletes at his school by supporting a new swim team. There is only one problem. The Cutter High School swim team doesn't even have a pool to practice in. T. J. Jones doesn't let this stop him, though. He recruits some of the school's most unpopular misfits: a fat boy, a one legged boy with a bad attitude, and a boy usually ridiculed for being retarded. T. J. Jones is determined to make sure that each of the boys earns a varsity letter jacket. This jacket is a highly coveted symbol that is usually reserved for white jocks who are buddies with the coaches that T. J. Jones despises so much.

As T. J. Jones helps the motley group of misfits to become an organized swim team he finds that they are also developing in other ways too. Under the influence of friendship and a feeling of being wanted the boys come to realize that their own worth does not depend on their popularity with the other students.

“Whale Talk” is a fairly broad reaching book. In reading it I felt that Chris Crutcher was trying to cover every issue available, from racism, to school corruption, to child abuse. “Whale Talk” is not exactly a polished masterpiece. I felt that Crutcher used far too much profanity. By choosing to tell the story through T. J. Jones he gives the novel a personal attitude, but T. J. Jones himself has an attitude half admirable, half disappointing. Overall “Whale Talk” was not a book that appealed to me. Sports and school popularity struggles can be good plot topics if they are handled properly. However, “Whale Talk” comes across as rough, with an ending that fails to satisfy.

“Whale Talk” is a book that I wouldn't waste my time reading.

Inkweaver Book Rating:

★★Plot

★★★Characters

★★Presentation

★★Overall

Your Rating:
Inkweaver Review 2009-05-31T10:03:00-05:00

10 replies so far. What are your thoughts?

jayny said...

The last days "The Kids' Right to Read Project" interviewed Author Chris Crutcher, who spoke about his experinece as one of the most challenged authors of all time.

If you're intrigued in such kind of stuff or wanna read more about the interview just visit our homepage (www.ncac.org) and join our blog (ncacblog.wordpress.com). It's very interesting!

We're glad about a lot comments as well as a lively discussion!

Greetings Jana

NathanKP said...

Thanks for sharing the link. I agree that some of Chris Crutcher's works are a little bit borderline.

Personally, I didn't like "Whale Talk" too much, and I don't think I would go out of my way to read more books by Chris Crutcher.

Anonymous said...

I'm a 17 yr old highschool student and I was assigned to read "Whale Talk" and at first I was dreading reading it, because who likes books assigned by teachers? No one. But I was surprised at how good the book really was, the teacher gave me almost a month to read the book, I finished it in 4 days. I loved every page of it.

Anonymous said...

I'm doing a project about Whale Talk and I personally LOVE it!

phsstudent said...

I'm a sixteen year old student and i was assigned to do an outside reading project on Whale Talk. From the first page, I honestly fell in love with the book. I really connected with it and I believe that Chris Crutcher is an amazing author. I thought that "Whale Talk" was one of the few books that really could really hit home for fellow high school students like myself

Anonymous said...

i dont see what's so wrong with cencership? can someone explain it to me.

Anonymous said...

i dont see anything wrong with cencership

Anonymous said...

Personally I liked Whale Talk however it did have its slow times

pharmacy said...

I really like this site, it's so important to know more about this topic, keep it up and of course every time I have time I'll love to check out again

KP said...

I was assigned this book for English and hated every second of it. I knew I hated it when I was on the sixth chapter and nothing interesting had happened and it was still on the exposition.